Skip to content
Lumino

Online payments

Shopify Payments Alternatives

Shopify Payments is the simplest way to take cards on a Shopify store, and for many merchants it is the right choice. Alternatives are worth considering when your business type is not supported, when you sell high-ticket or subscription products that need different risk handling, or when you take payments in places Shopify does not reach, such as invoices, sales calls and physical locations.

  • Guide
  • 10 min read
  • Reviewed November 2026
  • By the Lumino team

Summarize with

Key takeaways

  • Start from the reason you are looking. “Cheaper” alone is rarely enough once every fee is counted.
  • Shopify’s public pricing lists an additional fee for using third-party payment providers. Include it in the comparison.
  • Eligibility, account stability and off-store payments are the strongest reasons to add another provider.
  • You can run more than one provider. It does not have to be a replacement.
  • Test the checkout, refunds and reporting before you move live traffic.

What is a Shopify Payments alternative?

A Shopify Payments alternative is any payments provider, other than Shopify Payments, that a Shopify merchant uses to take money from customers. It can process the store’s orders in place of Shopify Payments, or handle only the payments that happen away from the store while the store checkout stays as it is.

The phrase covers two separate decisions. One is which provider processes the orders placed in your store. The other is which provider handles everything else you sell, such as invoices, phone orders and in-person sales, and you can answer the two differently.

Why do merchants look beyond Shopify Payments?

  • Eligibility. Shopify Payments is available only in certain countries and for certain business types. Some merchants are not offered it, and some lose it after a review.
  • Risk profile. High-ticket, subscription and pre-order models can attract holds on a provider built for mainstream retail.
  • Payments outside the store. Invoices, payment links sent on a sales call, wholesale orders and in-person sales often run outside Shopify.
  • Financing. Sellers of large-ticket goods may want specific BNPL options at checkout.
  • One view. Businesses with several stores or channels want one report across all of them.

What does switching cost?

As of 2026, Shopify’s public pricing describes an additional transaction fee, which varies by plan, when a store uses a third-party payment provider in place of Shopify Payments. Check Shopify’s own pricing page for the current terms on your plan.

That fee belongs in the calculation. Compare your total cost today with the total on the alternative: the new provider’s fees, plus Shopify’s third-party fee, minus whatever you stop paying. If the answer is close, the decision should rest on the other reasons above.

About the numbers

We do not quote Shopify’s fees here because they change and depend on your plan. Use the figures on Shopify’s site on the day you compare.

What should you look for in an alternative?

QuestionWhy it matters
Has my business model been underwritten as it really is?It determines whether the account stays stable when sales grow
Does it integrate with Shopify checkout?Customers should not notice the change
How are refunds and disputes handled?They should flow back into your order records
Can I see dispute and fraud ratios myself?E-commerce is where VAMP exposure sits
Does it cover payments outside the store?One provider for links, invoices and in-person sales simplifies reconciliation
What are the contract terms?Avoid long commitments while you are still testing

How should you compare providers, step by step?

A comparison is only useful if every option is measured the same way. Take the steps in this order and write the answers down.

  1. State in one sentence why you are looking.
  2. List every place you take payment, inside the store and outside it.
  3. Total what you pay today across all of them, from statements and not from price lists.
  4. Ask each candidate to price the same month of transactions, and add any platform fee that would apply on your plan.
  5. Ask how each one would underwrite your business model and what could prompt a review.
  6. See the checkout, the refund flow and the reports for yourself.
  7. Compare contract length and exit terms last, in writing.

If the option that comes out ahead on cost does not answer the reason in step one, go back to the reason. A small saving rarely makes up for an account that does not suit the way you sell.

Can you use more than one provider?

Yes, and for many merchants it is the sensible arrangement. Keep the store checkout where it works, and use a second provider for the payments the store does not handle well: high-ticket invoices, subscriptions billed outside Shopify, phone orders and in-person sales.

The trade-off is reporting in two places unless the second provider can bring it together.

Should you replace Shopify Payments, add to it or stay?

There are three possible outcomes, and staying is one of them. The table sets out what each changes and when it tends to fit.

OptionWhat changesTends to fit when
Stay on Shopify PaymentsNothingIt is available to you, the account is stable and most sales happen in the store
Add a second providerThe store checkout stays; other payments moveInvoices, phone orders or in-person sales are a real part of revenue
Use a third-party provider at checkoutAnother provider processes store ordersYour business type is not supported, or the account does not suit how you sell

The middle option changes the least, because nothing in the store has to move. It also gives you a working relationship with a second provider before you decide anything about checkout.

A worked example: how would a furniture store decide?

Consider a store on Shopify that sells made-to-order furniture, with a typical order around $2,500 and delivery some weeks after payment. A good part of its revenue comes from outside the store: trade customers are invoiced, and some buyers pay a deposit over the phone.

The owner writes down why she is looking, and it is not price. Large orders paid well before delivery make her nervous about holds, and her invoices and phone deposits sit in two other tools with their own reports.

She does the cost comparison anyway. She totals a month of fees across all three tools, asks a candidate to price that month, and adds to the store portion the third-party fee shown on Shopify’s pricing page for her plan. The store portion comes out close, so cost does not settle it.

What settles it is the split. She keeps the store checkout as it is and moves invoices and phone deposits to the second provider, once it has underwritten the made-to-order model. When a few months of reports sit in one place, she will look again at whether to change the checkout too.

Illustrative

This store is hypothetical and no fee or saving is implied. Shopify’s terms are on its own site, and whether another provider suits you depends on your plan, volume and reasons for looking.

What mistakes should you avoid?

  • Changing everything at once. Moving checkout, subscriptions and invoicing together makes it hard to tell which change caused a problem.
  • Forgetting stored cards and subscriptions. Ask both providers how existing customer payment details and recurring orders would be handled before you commit.
  • Describing the business as simpler than it is. An application that leaves out pre-orders or subscriptions sets up the review you were trying to avoid.
  • Closing the old account too soon. Refunds and disputes on past orders can still arrive after you stop taking new payments there.
  • Leaving customers uninformed. A new name on the card statement or a different payment page should be explained before it prompts unrecognized-charge disputes.

How does Lumino fit with Shopify?

Lumino lists Shopify among its integrations, alongside WooCommerce and others, and adds the payments around the store: payment links, invoicing, subscriptions, BNPL and in-person options.

Whether it makes sense for a particular store depends on your plan, volume and reasons for looking. We will tell you if staying on Shopify Payments is the better answer. Start with Lumino for e-commerce.

How do you switch without breaking checkout?

  1. Complete underwriting with the new provider before you change anything in the store.
  2. Connect it and run test orders, including a refund and a failed payment.
  3. Check that orders, payouts and taxes reconcile in your accounting.
  4. Go live at a quiet time, and watch approval rates for the first week.
  5. Keep the old provider available until you are confident.

How do you know whether the change worked?

Decide what you will measure before you switch, and record the figures for the month before. Useful measures are total payment cost across every channel, the share of payments approved, refunds and disputes, and the time spent reconciling.

Look at the same measures after the first full month and again a few months later. One month can mislead, because a launch, a sale or a seasonal dip changes the mix of orders.

If the numbers moved the wrong way, find out which part caused it before you reverse anything. Your new provider should be able to explain a change in approvals or cost from its own reports.

How Lumino helps

How does Lumino help a Shopify merchant?

  • Integrations

    Lumino lists Shopify among its integrations. The exact connection depends on your processing setup and on Shopify’s own rules for third-party payment providers, so ask us to confirm the route for your store.

  • Invoicing

    For sales that happen away from the store, invoicing sends an itemized invoice with a pay button, takes deposits and schedules reminders, in the same account as your other Lumino payments.

  • Reporting & Analytics

    Reporting & Analytics shows transactions, batches and deposits across your Lumino payment channels in one dashboard, so link, invoice and in-person payments are reconciled together and not tool by tool.

About this guide

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change, and they differ by business type. Check the current rules with your processor or counsel before changing how you price or accept payments.

FAQ

Common questions

What is a third-party payment provider on Shopify?

It is a payments company other than Shopify Payments that processes orders placed in a Shopify store. You apply to it directly, it underwrites your business, and your payouts for those orders come from it. See online payments for what an account of that kind covers at Lumino.

Can I use another payment processor on Shopify?

Yes. Shopify supports third-party payment providers. Per its public pricing as of 2026, an additional transaction fee applies when you do, and it varies by plan. Confirm the current terms on Shopify’s site.

Is an alternative to Shopify Payments cheaper?

Sometimes, but not automatically. Once Shopify’s third-party fee is included, the difference can be small. The stronger reasons are usually eligibility, account stability and payments outside the store.

Will customers see a different checkout?

That depends on the provider’s integration. Some keep the customer on Shopify’s checkout; others redirect to a hosted page. Ask to see it, and test it on a phone.

How do I know whether my business is eligible for Shopify Payments?

Check Shopify’s own published requirements, which are the only current source. Shopify sets eligibility by country and business type, so we do not summarize it here. If you are not offered it, or lose it after a review, look for a provider that underwrites your model up front. See faster merchant onboarding.

What happens to my subscriptions if I change payment provider?

It depends on where the subscriptions are billed and on whether stored payment details can be moved. Ask your current provider, your new one and any subscription app you use what a migration involves before you commit. Until that is clear, leave existing subscribers where they are and start new ones on the new setup. See subscriptions.

Who handles chargebacks if I use another provider?

The provider that processed the payment does. Disputes on its payments follow its process and deadlines, so with two providers you have two places to watch, and each needs a named owner on your side. Ask where disputes appear and how you are notified. The chargeback management guide explains the process.

How long does it take to switch payment provider?

There is no fixed timeline. The steps that take time are underwriting with the new provider, connecting and testing the integration, and reconciling the first payouts. A complete application that describes how you really sell is the part you control. The guide to accepting payments online sets out the steps.

Does Lumino replace Shopify?

No. Shopify is your store. Lumino is a payments platform that can work alongside it and cover the payments you take elsewhere.

Summarize with

Compare the options for your store.

Tell us your platform, your volume and what you sell, and we’ll set out the routes that are open to you.