If you take cards, you pay for it. The hard part is that the price is rarely one number. Statements mix network costs, brand fees, and the processor’s own markup, then dress the total as a “rate,” a bundle, or a long list of line items. This guide explains those pieces in plain English so you can read a quote, compare providers, and decide whether a change is worth it.
Why credit card processing fees feel opaque
Card payments move through several parties: the merchant, the merchant’s processor or gateway, the card networks (Visa, Mastercard and others), and the bank that issued the card. Each party takes a cut. Visa’s own overview of interchange and processing fees (opens in a new tab) and the Federal Reserve’s Regulation II pages on debit card interchange (opens in a new tab) point to the same basic split merchants see on statements: interchange, assessments, and acquirer or processor markup.
When a provider advertises “2.9% + 30¢,” that figure usually bundles those pieces into one price. When a provider sells interchange-plus, you see the network pieces separately and then a disclosed markup. Neither model is automatically “the cheapest.” They are different ways of packaging the same underlying costs.
The three building blocks
1. Interchange
Interchange is paid to the issuing bank—the bank that gave your customer their card. Rates vary by card brand, card product (debit, rewards, commercial), how the card was used (tap, chip, keyed, online), and merchant category. Networks publish interchange schedules; those schedules are detailed and change over time. You do not negotiate interchange with Visa or Mastercard directly as a typical merchant. You experience it through whatever pricing model your processor uses.
Practical implication: a business that takes many premium rewards cards online will usually see a higher average interchange than a grocery store taking mostly debit in person. That difference is real even when two shops pay the “same” advertised flat rate.
2. Assessments and network fees
Assessments are fees paid to the card networks. They are smaller than interchange in most consumer card cases, but they are not zero, and they appear under several names on full statements (brand fees, network fees, dues). Like interchange, they are largely outside your day-to-day negotiation with a salesperson.
3. Processor or acquirer markup
This is the part a provider actually sets: a percentage, a per-transaction fee, monthly fees, gateway fees, PCI-related fees, and other account charges. On interchange-plus, the markup is meant to be visible. On flat rate or tiered pricing, the markup is folded into the bundled rate, which can make apples-to-apples comparison harder.
Lumino publishes three merchant pricing models—flat rate, interchange-plus and dual pricing—on its pricing page. Published figures are starting points; what you pay still depends on your card mix and how you take payments.
Pricing models you will be offered
Flat rate
One percentage (often plus a fixed cents fee) for qualifying card transactions. Strengths: easy to forecast, easy to explain to a bookkeeper. Tradeoffs: you may overpay relative to true interchange on some debit-heavy volume, or the provider may carve out “non-qualified” transactions that price higher than the headline rate. Always ask what falls outside the advertised rate (keyed entry, international cards, rewards cards, refunds, chargebacks).
Interchange-plus (also called cost-plus)
You pay interchange and assessments at cost, plus a disclosed markup. Strengths: transparency; easier to audit; usually better once volume and card mix make the network cost material. Tradeoffs: statements are longer; month-to-month totals move with card mix. This is the model most statement reviews use when they say they will “show the true cost.”
Tiered (qualified / mid-qualified / non-qualified)
Transactions are sorted into buckets with different rates. Strengths: can look cheap on the qualified tier. Tradeoffs: many everyday cards miss the cheapest tier, so the blended rate surprises merchants. If you are on tiered pricing, ask for a recent breakdown of volume by tier.
Dual pricing and cash discount
Dual pricing shows a card price and a cash price and lets the customer choose. It is different from a hidden surcharge. Network and state rules still apply; disclosure and receipt language matter. Dual pricing does not erase interchange—it is a way some businesses recover acceptance costs while keeping the economics visible to the buyer. Lumino’s overview of reducing fees is in Reduce processing fees and the deeper guide How to reduce payment processing fees.
How to calculate your effective processing rate
Ignore the brochure for a moment. Pull one full monthly statement (or a 90-day series if volume swings).
- Add all processing-related fees for the period: percentages, authorizations, batch fees, gateway fees, PCI or non-compliance fees, monthly minimums, and chargeback fees if you want a fully loaded view.
- Divide by total card volume for the same period.
- Multiply by 100 for a percentage.
That percentage is your effective rate. Compare providers on effective rate for your mix, not on whoever’s homepage number is smaller. A fair savings analysis uses your statement; Lumino offers a custom savings analysis for that reason rather than quoting a universal savings figure.
Where fees hide on statements
Watch for:
- Monthly minimums that charge you if volume is low
- PCI non-compliance or “security” fees when a questionnaire is late
- Gateway or platform fees billed separately from the card rate
- AVS, voice auth, batch, or regulatory line items
- Equipment lease payments that are not processing but still hit cash flow
- Early termination or equipment buyout language in the contract, not on the statement
None of these line items are automatically improper. They are easy to miss when a pitch focuses only on the swipe rate.
Online, keyed and in-person costs are not the same
Card-not-present (online, phone, invoice link) transactions generally carry higher interchange and higher fraud and dispute risk than a tapped or chipped in-person sale. That is why e-commerce and online coaching businesses often see different economics than a café with mostly face-to-face debit.
If you sell high-ticket services online, ask any provider how they underwrite your average ticket, how reserves work if used, and what dispute tools you get. Fee shopping without risk context is how accounts get surprised later.
A practical checklist before you switch
- Request a blended effective rate from your current statement and from the new quote using the same month of volume.
- Ask whether the quote is flat, interchange-plus, or tiered, and what is excluded.
- Confirm monthly fees, gateway fees, and PCI fees in writing.
- Confirm payout timing (next-day, same-day options and any add-on cost).
- Read termination and equipment terms before you sign.
- For online businesses, ask about chargeback workflows and account review triggers.
Public references worth bookmarking: network interchange publications from Visa and Mastercard (updated periodically), and independent explainers that define interchange versus processor markup without selling a single brand.
How Lumino fits
Lumino is a payments, rewards and commerce platform for modern businesses. It is not itself a card network. Processing and related infrastructure run through Lumino’s processor, gateway and infrastructure partners. On pricing, Lumino publishes flat rate, interchange-plus and dual pricing on /pricing and invites merchants to send a statement for a savings analysis instead of promising a one-size savings percentage.
If your next step is operational—not just educational—start with the savings analysis or contact the team with a recent statement and a short note on how you take cards today (in person, online, invoices, or a mix).
Bottom line
Credit card processing fees are three stacked costs—interchange, assessments and markup—sold through several packaging models. Your decision quality rises when you calculate an effective rate from real volume, demand a quote on the same basis, and separate network costs you cannot change from markup and account fees you can. That is the difference between shopping a slogan and shopping a statement.