Flat rate and interchange-plus are two ways of packaging the same underlying card costs. One gives you a single number that is easy to budget. The other shows what the card networks charge and what your provider adds on top. Merchants who pick from a homepage percentage alone often miss which model fits their volume, ticket size and card mix. This comparison walks through both so you can decide with a statement in hand.
What both models are pricing
Every card sale carries three cost layers: interchange paid to the issuing bank, assessments and network fees paid to the brands, and the processor or acquirer markup. Visa’s overview of interchange and processing fees (opens in a new tab) describes interchange as a transfer between banks—not a fee merchants negotiate with Visa directly. Merchants instead pay a merchant discount to their financial institution or processor that typically includes those network pieces plus service costs. Debit interchange for many larger issuers is also shaped by the Federal Reserve’s Regulation II (opens in a new tab).
Credit card processing fees explained covers those building blocks in more depth. Here the question is narrower: how should those costs appear on your bill?
- Flat rate folds them into one advertised percentage, often with a per-transaction cents fee.
- Interchange-plus (also called cost-plus) shows interchange and assessments at cost, then a separate markup.
Neither erases network cost. They only change what you see and how you negotiate.
How flat rate works
With flat rate, you pay one percentage on qualifying card volume—sometimes plus a fixed amount per authorization. Bookkeeping is simple: forecast revenue, apply the rate, and you have a processing estimate. Many online platforms publish a single bundled rate for that reason. Lumino’s published flat-rate plan is 3.5% + $0.30 per transaction, with one rate for every card type and no separate card versus cash price for the customer. Details live on the pricing page.
Strengths of flat rate
- Predictable. Month-to-month totals move mainly with volume, not with which rewards cards showed up.
- Easy to explain to a bookkeeper, accountant or co-owner.
- Fast to quote when you are comparing providers at a high level.
- Fits many online sellers and businesses with larger tickets who value simplicity over line-item detail, which is how Lumino describes the plan’s fit on /pricing.
Tradeoffs of flat rate
- The headline rate is a blend. On some debit-heavy volume you may pay more than true network cost plus a modest markup; on premium rewards volume you may still be fine—or the provider may carve out “non-qualified” traffic at a higher rate.
- You need to ask what falls outside the advertised number: keyed entry, international cards, commercial cards, refunds, chargebacks, and monthly account fees.
- Auditing “what did the processor earn versus the network?” is harder because the pieces are not itemized the same way as on interchange-plus.
Flat rate is not a trick. It is a product design choice that trades transparency for simplicity.
How interchange-plus works
Interchange-plus passes through network costs and adds a disclosed markup—percentage, cents, or both—plus any monthly program fee the provider publishes. Lumino’s published interchange-plus plan is $48 per month, plus interchange and a set markup quoted for your business, with the two cost layers shown separately on the statement. Online payments can run on this plan as well as on flat rate; see the plan comparison on /pricing.
Strengths of interchange-plus
- Transparency. You can see what moved with card mix and what is the provider’s share.
- Easier to audit when a salesperson claims a lower “rate” but shifts cost into monthly or ancillary fees.
- Usually better suited to higher volume, where the markup is worth watching and card mix varies—again matching how Lumino positions the plan.
- Statement reviews and savings analyses often rebuild cost this way even when your current plan is flat or tiered.
Tradeoffs of interchange-plus
- Statements are longer and totals move when customers use more premium or commercial cards.
- Forecasting is a range, not a single percentage, unless you track your recent blend.
- A low markup with a high monthly fee can still lose to a clean flat rate at low volume—so always include the monthly line in the math.
Side-by-side: what changes for the merchant
| Dimension | Flat rate | Interchange-plus |
|---|---|---|
| What you see | One bundled rate (often + cents) | Network cost + disclosed markup |
| Month-to-month feel | More stable for a given volume | Moves with card mix |
| Best when | You want simple forecasts | You want to audit markup at scale |
| Customer price | Usually one price | Usually one price |
| Risk if you only shop the headline | Exclusions and monthly fees | Markup looks tiny while monthly fees add up |
Dual pricing is a third published path on Lumino: customers see a card price and a lower cash price, and the card price is designed to cover acceptance. It is not the same as flat rate or interchange-plus packaging; see dual pricing and the dual pricing guide if cash is a realistic tender for your buyers.
Which model tends to save money—and when
There is no universal winner. Use these patterns as hypotheses, then test them on your volume.
Flat rate often wins the “total cost of attention” test when
- Monthly card volume is modest and you would rather not reconcile a long statement.
- Your mix is stable and mostly consumer debit or everyday credit.
- Your team prices jobs with a simple percentage baked into margins.
- You sell online and want one rate across checkout, payment links and invoices.
Interchange-plus often wins the “true cost” test when
- Volume is high enough that a fraction of a percent of markup matters.
- You take many rewards, premium or commercial cards, so true interchange swings.
- You (or your bookkeeper) will actually read the interchange and markup lines.
- You are renegotiating and need a model where the provider’s share is visible.
A café with mostly tapped debit can look fine on a fair flat rate. A B2B seller with large commercial-card tickets may prefer interchange-plus so the markup does not hide inside a blended number. Same industry labels do not decide the model—ticket size, channel and card mix do.
How to compare them on your statement
Use the same method described in the fees guide and on Lumino’s savings analysis page: rebuild cost from your own numbers.
- Pick one full month (or 90 days if volume swings).
- Sum all processing-related fees: percentages, per-item fees, batch fees, gateway fees, PCI or non-compliance fees, monthly minimums or program fees, and chargeback fees if you want a fully loaded view.
- Divide by card volume for the same period.
- Multiply by 100. That percentage is your effective rate.
Then ask each provider for a quote on that same volume file:
- For flat rate: confirm the percentage, the cents fee, what is excluded, and every monthly fee.
- For interchange-plus: confirm the markup, the monthly program fee, and that interchange and assessments pass through at cost with no silent uplift.
If a quote cannot be restated as an effective rate on your file, it is not ready to compare.
effective rate = total fees ÷ total card volume × 100
Public network schedules change. You do not need to memorize Visa or Mastercard tables to choose a model; you need a provider who will price your file the same way on both structures.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Is the quote flat rate, interchange-plus, or tiered? Tiered (qualified / mid / non-qualified) is a different packaging again and often surprises merchants when everyday cards miss the cheapest tier.
- What is excluded from the headline rate?
- What are the monthly, gateway and PCI fees in writing?
- For interchange-plus, is the markup a percentage, cents, or both—and is there a monthly program fee?
- Are there early termination or equipment obligations if you leave?
- For online volume, how do card-not-present rates and dispute tools differ from in-person?
Also separate pricing model from product fit: payout timing, reporting, POS hardware and chargeback workflows matter as much as the rate once you are live. Lumino’s overview of fee reduction options sits in Reduce processing fees and the longer guide How to reduce payment processing fees.
How Lumino presents both
Lumino is a payments, rewards and commerce platform. It is not a card network. Processing runs through Lumino’s processor, gateway and infrastructure partners. On pricing, Lumino publishes three merchant models side by side—flat rate (3.5% + $0.30), dual pricing (0% processing cost to you when the program fits), and interchange-plus ($48 per month plus interchange and a set markup)—with no long-term contract and no setup fee on the published plans. The pricing page states those figures as published starting points and asks merchants to confirm every fee in writing for their account. Online payments run on flat rate or interchange-plus; dual pricing is aimed at in-person businesses whose customers can pay cash.
Rather than advertising a universal savings percentage, Lumino invites merchants to send a statement for a custom savings analysis that shows the models on their own numbers. That matches the comparison method in this article: effective rate first, packaging second.
If you are ready to open an account, get started (opens in a new tab). If you want the models laid out on your file first, use the savings analysis or contact the team with a recent statement and a short note on how you take cards (in person, online, invoices, or a mix).
Bottom line
Interchange-plus versus flat rate is a packaging choice, not a morality play. Flat rate buys simplicity and steadier forecasts. Interchange-plus buys visibility into markup once volume and card mix make that visibility valuable. The model that “saves merchants money” is the one with the lower effective rate on your volume after monthly and ancillary fees—not the one with the prettier homepage percentage. Price both structures on the same statement, read the exclusions, and only then decide.